Manningtree Chess Club Match Results.

A-Team B-Team C-Team N/S Cup Suffolk Cup/Plate U145 U125

NORFOLK/SUFFOLK CUP
Semi-FinalFinal
Bury St Edmunds
Ipswich

Bury St Edmunds

Manningtree

5

1

Saxmundham
Manningtree


 Bury St Edmunds 28/06/14Manningtree
1Michael Harris 218 1 - 0Andrew P Lewis 215
2Mark R Le-Vine 192 1 - 0Philip J Hutchings 162
3Alexander John Peters 187 1 - 0Robert W Stephens 147
4Stephen W Ruthen 175 1 - 0John WF McAllister 133
5Jonathan L Collins 159 ½ - ½Carl Phillips 125
6Jaden Jermy 158 ½ - ½David Welsh 117
   5 - 1
Throughout the last 2 seasons, Manningtree A have started most matches as favourites. However, on this occasion the Manningtree team were not unduly burdened by the weight of expectations.
  The Norfolk-Suffolk Cup has slightly different rules from the other competitions in which Manningtree participate. A nuance of these rules is that each club may only enter one team. This rule tends to advantage larger clubs, and meant that on this evening we faced the might of the Bury A, B, C teams and Junior club combined. Added to that, we lacked two of our regular A team members, Adam & Leon. Hardly a propitious outlook for our final match of the season!
  This match had a unique atmosphere, created by regular cheers from an inebriated audience packed into a nearby bar, watching the England-Belgium World Cup match. Would Bury v Manningtree turn out to be another Germany v Korea?
  Alas, it was not our night. Heavily out graded, our Boards 2-4 did not overly trouble their Bury counterparts. Andy had more chances in his game, but playing uncharacteristically swiftly, missed a nice tactic by his opponent and soon lost.
  The positive highlights of the Manningtree performance were provided by boards five and six. David obtained a creditable draw against Bury's most promising junior. Carl outplayed his higher rated opponent, won the exchange and was about to start eating his opponent's extra pawns. But short of time, Carl cautiously offered a draw. Had this game been critical for the match, one would have expected Carl to go on to win. (Indeed at the point when the draw was agreed, aside from the time situation, his opponent's position was almost resign-able.)
  1-5 sounds an alarming score-line. But with a fair wind we might have held the match to 2½-3½. No situation is without hope; and perhaps one year Manningtree will add the Norfolk-Suffolk Club to their silverware collection. I can hardly wait for next season!

 Saxmundham 15/05/18Manningtree
1John A Feavyour 175 0 - 1Adam C Taylor 209
2Malcolm J Lightfoot 157 ½ - ½Andrew P Lewis 215
3Dominic A Carter 145 0 - 1Philip J Hutchings 162
4Michael E Usher 135 ½ - ½Jim Buis 155
5Samuel Gaffney 123 ½ - ½John WF McAllister 133
6Mark Nevison 98 1 - 0Default
   2½ - 3½
The omens for this match did not start well tonight. First David was held up at work and was running late and had to make his own way to Saxmundham. Adam was caught up in London traffic and was likewise running late, but as he was providing the transport, that meant Andy and Phil would also be late. John and Jim were therefore our only two players on site at 7.30, but as Saxmundham didn't appear to be in any hurry for a prompt start, we weren't either. Meanwhile, our three top boards managed to make up some time on their way and arrived just before the match got under way (was that Adam's driving, or just an empty road?). Unfortunately David was not so lucky and also had a problem locating the venue and went home a very unhappy bunny.
  Omens not withstanding, we managed our first win in this competition, at least the first win we can find a record of. Last year we drew both of our matches 3-3, and before that we have to go back thirty six years before we can find a record of Manningtree appearing in this competition, and we lost that match 4-2. Of course, we may have made other appearances that have yet to be unearthed that may show us winning, but one thing's for certain, this is the first time Manningtree have reached the final of the Suffolk section of this cup.
  Jim finished first and faced 1.b3, a move that seems to be having something of a renaissance. Steady development on both sides led to a rather bland game, and with an early exchange of queens and three minor pieces the prospects for fireworks were virtually zero. John followed in similar fashion and after thirty moves was offered a draw. After looking at the other games, and being unable to determine if they would deliver sufficient points he turned it down, only to offer it himself several moves later when the position had become even more sterile.
  Phil then levelled the match. From a Scotch Opening by transposition, he eventually won his opponent's a-pawn and advanced his own a-pawn to the seventh rank, tying his opponent's queen rook to passive defence. His opponent tried a counter action on the king's side with queen, rook and h-pawn, but Phil responded with an advance of his e and f pawns, creating a passed e-pawn, which also reached the seventh with decisive threats, forcing immediate resignation.
  Adam now put us in front with a somewhat unconventional opening, but very active piece play in which Adam was "forced" to sacrifice the exchange. Mind you, his opponent was unwise to accept it, and while the ending looked doubtful to most of us (even though Adam now had two pieces for his rook) Adam was in no doubt, he saw the win and executed it with his usual precision.
  We now had the minimum three points we needed to progress to the final, as board elimination would see us through in the event of a tied match. Although at this stage the tie-break appeared purely academic as Andy was cruising to victory (or so we thought). After a long game, with two extra pawns in a Q+B v Q+N endgame, Andy appeared to be making slow, but inexorable, progress towards victory. In an easily won position, Andy sacrificed queen for knight to force home his passed a-pawn, expecting his opponent to resign. But wait: the queen capture prevented the pawn's advance, leaving Andy with a lost position! However, his opponent (perhaps rather generously) felt that he did not deserve the full point, and sportingly accepted Andy's draw offer.